Fixed vs. Variable Rate Mortgages – Which One is Best for You?

When it comes to choosing a mortgage, one of the biggest decisions you'll face is fixed vs. variable rates.

It’s a classic battle—security vs. savings, stability vs. flexibility, predictability vs. risk.

Some homeowners swear by fixed rates, locking in their payments and sleeping soundly at night. Others prefer to ride the market with a variable rate, taking advantage of historically lower costs over time.

But what if I told you that you don’t always have to choose just one? There are mortgage products that allow you to blend fixed and variable rates, giving you the best of both worlds.

Let’s break down:

• When to choose a fixed-rate mortgage
• How to leverage a variable-rate mortgage for long-term savings
• Market trends and how they affect mortgage rates

By the end, you’ll know exactly which strategy suits your financial goals.

---

When to Choose a Fixed-Rate Mortgage

A fixed-rate mortgage locks in your interest rate for the term (e.g., 5 years), meaning your payments never change—no matter what happens in the market.

Who Should Consider a Fixed Rate?

✔️ You’re risk-averse and value stability.

• If the thought of fluctuating mortgage payments keeps you up at night, a fixed-rate mortgage offers peace of mind.

✔️ You have a tight budget and need consistency.

• If every dollar of your monthly budget is accounted for, having a predictable mortgage payment can help with financial planning.

✔️ Interest rates are at historic lows.

• If fixed rates are already near rock bottom, locking in protects you from future increases.

✔️ You’re planning to stay in the home for a long time.

• If you know you won’t be selling or refinancing anytime soon, a fixed rate locks in stability for years.

Example: The Cost of Certainty

Sarah is buying her first home. She qualifies for:

• 5-year fixed rate: 5.5%
• 5-year variable rate: 4.8% (Prime – 0.5%)

Sarah wants to sleep easy, so she chooses the fixed rate. Even if variable rates drop, she doesn’t have to worry—her payment stays the same.

But here’s the downside…

---

How to Leverage a Variable-Rate Mortgage for Long-Term Savings

A variable-rate mortgage fluctuates based on the prime rate. When interest rates go down, your payment or amortization drops—meaning you pay less interest.

Historically, variable rates save homeowners more money than fixed rates over time.

Who Should Consider a Variable Rate?

✔️ You have financial flexibility.

• If your budget can handle potential increases in payments, a variable rate can save you money in the long run.

✔️ You want to take advantage of rate drops.

• If market conditions suggest rates could fall, a variable rate lets you ride the wave downward.

✔️ You’re comfortable taking a calculated risk.

• Statistically, variable rates outperform fixed rates about 80% of the time.

✔️ You plan to pay off your mortgage faster.

• Variable-rate mortgages often have lower penalties for breaking early, which makes them ideal for those planning to refinance or sell before the term ends.

Example: The Savings of a Variable Rate

James also qualifies for:

• 5-year fixed: 5.5%
• 5-year variable: 4.8%

Instead of playing it safe, he chooses the variable rate. If rates stay low for three years before rising, he could save thousands in interest costs.

By the time his rate goes up, he has already paid down more principal, meaning he owes less when higher rates hit.

---

What If You Could Get the Best of Both Worlds?

Many homeowners don’t realize that you don’t have to pick just one.

Option 1: Split Mortgages (Fixed + Variable Blend)

Some lenders allow you to split your mortgage into multiple portions, meaning:

• Part of your mortgage is fixed, providing stability.
• Part is variable, giving you access to lower rates and potential savings.

This is a great option for those who want to hedge their bets—you get the security of a fixed rate while still benefiting from the potential savings of a variable rate.

Example:
Emily has a $500,000 mortgage. She decides to go with:

• $250,000 at a 5-year fixed rate of 5.5%
• $250,000 at a 5-year variable rate of 4.8%

Even if variable rates increase, only half her mortgage is affected—giving her a balanced strategy.

---

Option 2: The Mortgage + HELOC Combo

Another advanced strategy is using a re-advanceable mortgage (a mortgage that includes a HELOC).

How it works:

• Your mortgage has both a fixed and HELOC portion.
• Every time you make a payment, the principal you pay down becomes available in the HELOC.
• You can use the HELOC to make lump sum payments on the fixed portion, reducing interest costs.
• Eventually, you convert the HELOC balance into a new fixed or variable mortgage portion.

Why it’s powerful:

• You get the security of a fixed mortgage but the flexibility of a HELOC.
• You can aggressively pay down your mortgage while keeping access to your equity.

Example:
Mike has a $400,000 mortgage structured as:

• $300,000 fixed at 5.5%
• $100,000 HELOC at 6.5%

Each month, he borrows from the HELOC to make lump sum payments on the fixed portion, reducing the mortgage balance faster. Over time, he refinances the HELOC portion into another fixed mortgage, lowering his overall costs.

---

Market Trends and How They Affect Mortgage Rates

When Do Fixed Rates Make Sense?

• When interest rates are low. Locking in a fixed rate during a low-rate environment ensures you don’t get caught in a future rate hike cycle.
• When inflation is rising. Central banks increase interest rates to cool inflation, which means variable rates could increase significantly.
• When the economy is uncertain. If global events or economic downturns are expected, a fixed rate provides stability.

When Do Variable Rates Make Sense?

• When interest rates are stable or falling. If rates aren’t expected to rise, a variable rate allows you to pay less interest.
• When the economy is slowing down. Central banks lower rates to stimulate borrowing, which benefits variable-rate holders.
• When you plan to break your mortgage early. Variable mortgages have lower penalties than fixed mortgages, which can save you thousands if you sell or refinance.

---

Final Thoughts: Which One Is Best for You?

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer.

✔️ If you need stability and predictability, go with a fixed rate.
✔️ If you want long-term savings and can handle fluctuations, go variable.
✔️ If you want to hedge your bets, consider a split mortgage.
✔️ If you want maximum flexibility, look at a mortgage + HELOC strategy.

The best way to decide? Work with a mortgage expert who can analyze your financial goals and customize the perfect mortgage strategy for you.

Want to explore your best mortgage options? Let’s talk!